The Growing Narcissism of Selfies

By Lee Williams, Communication Activist 

scientists-have-announced-a-new-unit-to-accurately-measure-narcissism-the-selfie-per-hour

Photo by Beware of Images

Selfies are everywhere. If you have more than one social media account it’s possible that you encounter at least five selfies per day. Selfie-types range far and wide, from capturing candid moments to the dreaded duck face. Though some selfies are entirely innocent and fun, there is a much more, extreme element to posting one’s image via social media. The extreme side of selfies are in their presentation: When did it become commonplace to showcase ratchet behavior, as in girls going duckface, dolled up, while in filthy bathrooms (for more on ratchet culture, read my post on America’s Unhealthy Obsession with Ratchet Culture), subtle cleavage shots, or men seeking validation by posting flex pics? With the present reality of the world as a digital marketplace, two considerations emerge when examining selfies:

1) Are they a harmless bi-product of a culture of digital immersion, or…

2) Do they represent growing, wide narcissism that reeks of attention-seeking?

The purpose of this article is not to demonize selfies, but to explore the narcissistic intentions. The motivation behind taking an internet selfie is characterized by purpose of the selfie, controlling the image, and emotional validation.

Purpose of the Selfie

In sociologist Erving Goffman’s 1956 groundbreaking book The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life, he associates face-to-face interactions as similar to theatrical performances. Goffman believed that individuals put on masks around others depending on the situation, following a theme of chameleon-like behavior, in order to control or guide the impression that others may take away from them. Though Goffman never lived to see social media, we can easily adapt his studies to online behaviors. Questions emerge:

  • Why do people feel the need to take selfies?
  • Is the user bored?
  • Are they looking to get noticed, or to preserve a moment in time?

Selfies are innocent enough when capturing a stand-out moment for the user, but what about selfies that have no discernible meaning or purpose? The answer, I believe, lies in the intent of presentation and desired outcome. There is more going on than the mere duck face.

selfie gone bad

When Animals Attack: Selfie Edition

Goffman called this behavior the “dramaturgical analysis”, which proclaims that people portray their lives as a theatrical performance where they can control or elicit the intended reaction from the audience. Could it be that the control of the selfie is then only a tool to produce a response, which is reflected in positive likes or comments? In an internet dominated culture, our personalities can become harder to translate beyond the written word. Photos are powerful, emotional translators and controlling the selfie photo has never been easier. Instagram and other photo apps help manipulate photos, or to advertise a physical feature / personality that may be overlooked in the real world. It can be claimed that people manipulate selfies in order to elicit a self-esteem boost.

http://wittyandpretty.com/2013/11/01/the-16-worst-types-of-selfies/

The “I live in filth” selfie, as demonstrated by Snookie (from Trey Humphreys article “The 16 Worst Types of Selfies”).

Controlling the image

Selfies have more choreography to them than a music video. There is active production, strategy, and time put into Mr. Gymrat’s slight flex when he shares a photo of his pre-gym workout, or Mrs. LookAtMe’s cuteness when posting a “no filter”.

girls be like

On social media, you are your own public relations firm and selfies are a form of controlling your image. Internet culture and a wireless society has created a virtual reality where compliments now equal “likes” and “comments”, which could lead to low self-esteem in the real world when the equivalent of “likes” and compliments are not the same. To balance, this would create a need to focus more on ones online persona than who they are as a person.

Blogger Tim Urban’s description for Internet users who abuse the internet are a direct connection for selfie motivation, which include one or more of these five motivations:

1) Image Crafting. The person wants to affect the way people think of him/her.

2) Narcissism. The person’s looks are so good, yet they are so humble or their lives so interesting, that they must be shared with the universe.

3) Attention Craving. The person wants attention.

4) Jealousy Inducing. The person wants to make people jealous of him/her or his/her life/body/talents.

5) Loneliness. The person is feeling lonely and wants Facebook to make it better.

Emotional Validation

The root motivation of selfies, in my opinion, is emotional validation. Facebook is infested with the five motivations not just in selfies, but in status updates as well. Selfies are a quick dose of self esteem, readily available at the user’s disposal. Self esteem boosts and physical validation equalize the emotional impact of online media in contrast to what one does not get in the real world.

Everyone who gets on Facebook and Instagram knows the feeling that they will get before they post a selfie. The sense of predictability is part of what motivates users to take, edit, and then post a selfie. This is feeling is similar to fast food. You know how you’ll feel if you indulge in a greasy bag of heaven from McDonalds but, if you don’t feel like indulging, you know how you could feel if you so choose to swallow 1,000 calories in one sitting. Selfies bring emotional validation, which brings comfort, which brings control. Some people need that control.

Yes. There can be strong narcissism behind the majority of selfies. Our wireless society has created new forms of expression and the selfie is just one of many forms of emotional control. Though purpose of the selfie can easily disregard narcissism, controlling the image and emotional validation cannot. In a reality where the physical self is overlooked, the online persona balances out the crave for attention with self esteem boosts for the user even if, sadly, they feel the need to post multiple selfies per day to feel better.

Follow or contact the  Communication Activist via WordPress, email (comm.activist@gmail.com), or stay by liking the Communication Activist’s official Facebook page

Sources:

Adler, P.; Adler, P.; Fontana, Andrea (1987). “Everyday Life Sociology”. Ann Rev Sociol 13: 217–35. doi:10.1146/annurev.so.13.080187.001245.

Goffman, E. (1974). Frame analysis: An essay on the organization of experience. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University

The 16 Worst Types of Selfies (http://wittyandpretty.com/2013/11/01/the-16-worst-types-of-selfies/)

10 comments

  1. David · November 8, 2013

    Hey Lee, wassup.

    Great article man. I thought I’d throw my hat in the ring, get a dialogue going.

    Just out of curiosity though, do you lean to either side of the fence with regards to whether selfies should be seen as a worrying sign of things to come, or birth-pangs of the digital age?

    I don’t mean to slip into generalities. Your angle of viewing selfies as a form of emotional validation just got me thinking: are they a sign of a decaying culture with shallow values and — like you said — narcissistic personalities; or, is it a kind of adaptation we’ve built to compensate for the declining face-to-face intimacy that used to provide those emotional needs?

    I feel like we’re all just so new to this whole global community thing the internet’s giving us. Behaviors like this just make me picture a big sugared-up kid in a candy store — trying everything in the place cause he don’t any better.

    Just my two-cents.

    Like the work man.

    D

    Like

    • commactivist · November 8, 2013

      David, thanks for the read and your comment! After giving your question some thought last night, selfies in my opinion are just behaviors that have come about from the digital age. Humans have been obsessed with their images for ages, such as artists doing self portraits and statues of themselves, to glamour shots and such. Some selfies are harmless and don’t bother me the least , but others are obviously being used to elicit a response, whether compliments or otherwise. Narcissism just has its way of working itself through our mediums when they become more and more personalized, especially since, as you said, we are living in an age of declining face-to-face interactions and intimacy. By no means do I feel this is a downfall of society, but it could be a representation of that lack of intimacy.

      For example, Vines, in my opinion, are spiritual successors to selfies, as they are hilarious but still subtly eliciting a response in regards to who is featured, their style of dress or lack of dress, attraction, and “fun showcase” nature, but we do not regard them in the same light as selfies (at least not yet).

      Social media is still developing and we are still adjusting to how we individualize it to our own lives, so in a way we all are sugared-up kids in a candy store, whether we take selfies or not.

      P.S. You got a guest post whenever you’d like!

      Like

  2. Pingback: How Do We Deal With Vanity? | Painting On Scars
  3. Pingback: America’s Pursuit of Unattainable Beauty | The Communication Activist
  4. SEO · March 21, 2014

    Hello there, just became alert to your blog through Google, and found that it is really informative.
    I am gonna watch out for brussels. I’ll appreciate
    if you continue this in future. A lot of people
    will be benefited from your writing. Cheers!

    Like

  5. http://upmodelmanagement.com/ · April 19, 2014

    Thank you this much. First post which has impacted me in 2014

    Like

  6. yahoo.com · April 21, 2014

    I have been surfing on-line more than three hours as of late, but I never discovered any attention-grabbing article like yours.
    It is beautiful worth enough for me. In my view,
    if all webmasters and bloggers made excellent content as you probably did, the internet will likely be much
    more useful than ever before.

    Like

  7. Brian · September 25, 2014

    You share interesting things here. I think that your page can go viral easily,
    but you must give it initial boost and i know how to do it,
    just type in google for – wcnu traffic increase

    Like

    • commactivist · September 26, 2014

      Thanks Brian. I have been trying to go viral for a while. Do you think it is worth the penny to invest in wcnu?

      Like

  8. Luisa · September 7

    I’m excited to uncover this page. I want to to thank
    you for your time for this particularly wonderful read!!
    I definitely liked every bit of it and i also have you book-marked
    to check out new things on your site.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s